The Cost of “Never Switching Off”
Permanent alertness has become so normal that many people no longer notice it.
You wake up, and your mind is already scanning: messages, tasks, risks, news, responsibilities. Even when nothing is urgent, something in you stays braced, like you are waiting for the next hit.
We tend to label this state as adulthood, ambition, being responsible, or “just how life is now.”
But your biology hears something different. It hears “no return to safety”.
And that is where the real cost begins, because stress is not the villain. A stress response that never completes its cycle is.
Your Stress System Was Built for Sprints, Not Marathons
A stress response is a survival mechanism.
When a threat appears, your body mobilises fast: heart rate rises, attention narrows, glucose becomes available, muscles tense, and pain sensitivity shifts. It is useful when the threat is real and short-lived.
Then the threat passes, and a healthy nervous system does something essential: it returns to baseline.
The big challenge in the modern world is that life demands constantly and is constantly uncertain, and so there is no return to baseline.
Deadlines roll into meetings. Meetings roll into notifications. Notifications roll into social pressure and global news. You may be physically safe, but your nervous system keeps receiving “not safe yet” signals: unpredictability, evaluation, time pressure, conflict, financial uncertainty, and the sense of never being fully caught up.
Your body does not neatly separate “predator” from “boss who might be disappointed.” If the situation involves uncertainty, loss of control, or social threat, it is perceived as dangerous.
Permanent Alertness Hides Behind “Functioning”
When people imagine chronic stress, they picture panic attacks or visible anxiety. But chronic stress often masquerades as permanent alertness.
It can look like:
struggling to relax even during downtime
light sleep, early waking, or waking tired
constant checking behaviour (phone, email, bank balance, news)
irritability, impatience, or a shorter fuse
overthinking, mental rehearsing, second-guessing
difficulty focusing unless pressure is high
feeling flat when things are calm
Some people experience it as restlessness, others as exhaustion. Many live in the confusing combination of both: tired, but unable to switch off.
You can be “fine” and still be braced. And because you are still functioning, you may not realise the price you are paying to function.
When Stress Becomes Baseline, Your Body Adapts
Here is the part that makes permanent alertness so tricky: the body is an excellent adapter.
If your system senses that stress is the new normal, it adjusts to help you keep performing. You may become:
more vigilant
quicker to react
more sensitive to interruption
less tolerant of uncertainty
faster to anticipate problems
better at staying “on”
From the outside, this can look like competence. You stay ahead. You manage everything before it becomes a problem. People describe you as “high-performing.”
But internally, you are not calm. You are braced.
Over time, bracing can become an identity. You start to believe your value is tied to vigilance. You may even feel proud of how much you can carry.
The problem is that this “capacity” is often funded by what you could call a stress loan. And stress loans always come with interest.
Your Nervous System Is Always Scanning
A helpful way to understand this is through the lens of the autonomic nervous system and safety signalling.
Your body is constantly scanning for cues of safety and threat, many of them subtle: facial expressions, tone of voice, predictability, environment, relational tension, noise, and interruption.
When your system detects safety, it opens up the functions that make life feel like life: digestion, deep sleep, emotional regulation, creativity, curiosity, and connection.
When safety cues are absent, it prioritises survival: protect, mobilise, prepare.
Safety cues can be simple:
predictable routines
warm tone and calm presence
uninterrupted time
environments that feel orderly and spacious
supportive touch
being with people who do not require performance
Threat cues can also be simple:
constant unpredictability
criticism, or anticipation of criticism
social tension
multitasking and constant switching
endless noise
the sense that rest must be earned
If your day contains many threat cues and few safety cues, your body can stay on alert even when your conscious mind says, “Nothing is wrong.”
This is why “just relax” advice often fails. The system is not refusing calm out of stubbornness. It is refusing calm because it does not trust calm.
Permanent Alertness Narrows Your Thinking
A chronically stressed brain does not think better. It thinks more narrowly.
Stress shifts cognition toward:
threat detection
short-term decision-making
habit-based responding
black-and-white thinking
faster judgments with less nuance
That is brilliant in emergencies. It is limiting in relationships, strategy, creativity, and long-term planning.
When you live in permanent alertness, you often lose:
cognitive flexibility
working memory
patience for complexity
emotional regulation
the capacity to plan long-term without fatigue
Then your mind does something very human: it makes it personal.
“I’m losing it.”
“I’m lazy.”
“My attention is broken.”
“I’m not who I used to be.”
Often, it is not a character flaw. It is stress physiology doing what it was designed to do: prioritising survival over flourishing.
Attention Is Not Infinite
Even if you remove stress from the conversation, modern life has another quiet tax, namely fragmentation.
Attention is a limited resource. When it is repeatedly interrupted, your brain pays “switching costs.”
You lose depth, coherence, and creative integration. You might stay busy all day, yet end the day with the unsettling feeling that nothing landed.
It shows up as:
shallow thinking
reduced creativity
increased irritability
persistent restlessness
lower satisfaction, even when things are going well
Cal Newport calls part of this problem “deep work” loss, but it’s bigger than productivity. It is about the mind losing the conditions it needs for meaning-making.
And here is the kicker: constant stimulation can start to feel normal. Silence can feel strange. Stillness can feel unsafe.
Why Switching Off Can Feel Uncomfortable
For many people, the difficulty is not knowing that rest is good. It is that rest feels psychologically exposed.
Stillness removes distractions, and distractions often protect us from uncomfortable thoughts, unresolved emotions, and existential questions.
So we fill the space. We scroll. We check. We “stay informed.” We stay reachable.
Noise becomes regulation.
But constant stimulation prevents emotional processing. What is not felt does not disappear. It waits.
If you have trained your system to run from discomfort, switching off can feel like you are walking into a room you have been avoiding. It is no wonder you reach for your phone.
The Performance Trap
In high-achievement cultures, availability is mistaken for commitment. Being reachable becomes a proxy for being valuable. Rest begins to feel like negligence.
It is especially common when identity is tightly bound to competence and output. If you only feel worthy when producing, rest threatens the story you rely on.
That is why many driven people do not just feel tired. They feel guilty when they stop.
So they keep the engine running and call it maturity.
What Permanent Alertness Does to Relationships
A braced nervous system changes how you interpret other people.
Neutral signals can start to feel threatening. Tone gets misread. Silence becomes suspicious. Minor disappointments feel bigger. Feedback feels like an attack. Your window for patience shrinks.
This is why chronic stress often shows up at home as:
conflict over small things
emotional withdrawal
sarcasm and irritability
reduced libido
feeling alone in the same room
You become less emotionally available not because you do not care, but because your body is busy managing threat. It is difficult to be generous when your nervous system believes you are under pressure.
The Real Cost is Not Stress, It Is The Erosion of Recovery
Most people can handle stress. What breaks people down is stress without recovery.
When the nervous system does not return to baseline often enough, you start to lose the restorative function of rest itself. Sleep becomes lighter. Downtime becomes “rest while scanning.” Joy becomes harder to access.
You may still have pleasant moments, but they do not land deeply. They do not restore you. They do not change your inner weather.
Over time, the body expresses the truth through symptoms:
chronic fatigue
headaches and muscle tension
digestive issues
blood pressure changes
emotional volatility
weakened immunity
heightened inflammation and pain sensitivity
Teaching Your Body That Safety Exists Again
The problem is not solved by one holiday or a single perfect meditation session. Those can help, but they do not retrain a baseline.
Baseline changes through repetition.
What helps is creating reliable safety cues, again and again, until your nervous system starts believing them.
Here are practical ways to do that without turning your life into a wellness project.
1. Predictable rest (not “when I get a gap”)
Schedule decompression the way you schedule meetings. Your nervous system responds more to reliability than to intention.
2. Reduce digital interruption in pockets, not perfection
Phones are not evil. Constant checking is a training program. It teaches your system that something might always be urgent. Create unreachable pockets, even if they are short.
3. Slow movement that signals regulation
Walking, stretching, mobility work, and gentle strength training. Not everything must be optimised. Some movement is to remind the body that it is safe to come down.
4. Nature as nervous system recalibration
Natural environments tend to reduce sensory assault and offer non-threatening stimuli. It is not aesthetic. It is physiological.
5. Supportive relationships where you can stop performing
Your nervous system learns safety through people. Choose time with those who make you feel more like yourself, not more managed.
6. Boundaries that reduce emotional labour
Fewer conversations where you manage someone else’s mood. Fewer commitments that require constant self-suppression. More honest “no’s.”
7. Micro-repairs throughout the day
Tiny returns to baseline matter: a slow exhale, a pause before responding, a short walk without your phone, stillness after a meeting. You are not chasing a perfectly calm life. You are building more returns.
The principle is simple: you cannot think your way out of a nervous system pattern. You have to live your way into a new baseline.
A Final Thought
Permanent alertness is often praised because it appears to be diligence. It looks like ambition. It looks like someone who can handle pressure.
But it costs you recovery. It costs you emotional availability. It costs you depth of joy, because joy requires the body to believe it can stand down.
The goal is not to eliminate stress. The goal is to teach your body that safety exists again.
Until next time, remember that wellness is not about functioning under pressure forever. It is about returning to baseline often enough to remain whole.
Dion Le Roux
References
Baumeister, R.F., & Tierney, J. (2011). Willpower: Rediscovering the Greatest Human Strength. Penguin.
Kaplan, S. (1995). ‘The restorative benefits of nature: Toward an integrative framework’. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 15(3), pp. 169–182.
Leroy, S. (2009). ‘Why is it so hard to do my work? The challenge of attention residue when switching between work tasks. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, 109(2), pp. 168–181.
McEwen, B.S. and Morrison, J.H. (2013). ‘The brain on stress: Vulnerability and plasticity of the prefrontal cortex over the life course’. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 14, pp. 825–834.
Newport, C. (2016). Deep Work: Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World. Grand Central Publishing.
Ophir, E., Nass, C. and Wagner, A.D. (2009). ‘Cognitive control in media multitaskers’. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(37), pp. 15583–15587.
Porges, S.W. (2011). The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, and Self-Regulation. W.W. Norton.
Sapolsky, R.M. (2004). Why Zebras Don’t Get Ulcers (3rd ed.). Holt Paperbacks.
Sonnentag, S. and Fritz, C. (2007). ‘The Recovery Experience Questionnaire: Development and validation of a measure for assessing recuperation and unwinding from work’. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), pp. 204–221.
Sterling, P. (2012). ‘Allostasis: A model of predictive regulation’. In: Fink, G. (ed.) Stress Science: Neuroendocrinology. Academic Press.